Sounds like Captains John and Susan dropped the hook in the nearby “Islamorada Anchorage, and then dinghied into Lorelei. Clearly, they had an unfortunate experience there.

We also anchored off the Lor-E-Lei and went in for refreshments and dinner. It was early so we sat at the bar (in the shade) and had a few adult beverages and then had dinner. Dinner was OK except the Fritters were raw inside. We paid, no complaining, and headed to the outside to sit and listen to the entertainment which had just kicked off. One more beer and we were heading back to the boat. The Waitress rudely informed us that we could not sit out there unless we ordered food. No signs stating such. I told her that I had already spent 50 bucks with tip and she said,’I make my money from tips.’ and told us we could not sit. Rude wait staff will always cause patrons to leave. Stay away from this place unless that is OK with you.
John and Susan

My experience here is: Nice place, Beautiful Sunsets, sandy beach outdoor seating with torches lit, nice atmosphere, great live entertainment, kids have room to run, mediocre food.
Been here several times and never had a problem with the staff but then again I was eating or drinking until I left’¦.. you can sit at the bar and listen to the music if you’re not going to order food, it’s just as close to the stage as the sandy area, just on the other side of the stage and still outdoors.
Jules Robinson

Click Here To View the Cruisers’ Net’s Florida Keys Anchorage Directory Listing For The Islamorada Anchorage

Click Here To View the Cruisers’ Net’s Florida Keys Marina Directory Listing For Lor-e-lei Restaurant, Cabana Bar, and Marina