Visit Logged
  • Select Region
    • All Regions
    • VA to NC Line
    • North Carolina
    • South Carolina
    • Georgia
    • Eastern Florida
    • Western Florida
    • Florida Keys
    • Okeechobee Waterway
    • Northern Gulf
    • Bahamas
    • New York
    • Ohio
    • Pennsylvania
    • Washington
    • Puerto Rico
    • Minnesota
    • Maryland
    • Tennessee
    • NW Waters
    Order by:
    • Bow Wars: X-Bow vs. Axe Bow – Loose Cannon

      Cruisers Net publishes Loose Cannon articles with Captain Swanson’s permission in hopes that mariners with saltwater in their veins will subscribe. $7 per month or $56 for the year; you may cancel at any time.

       
         
       
      Forwarded this email? Subscribe here for more

      When all else fails, try journalism.


      Bow Wars: X-Bow vs. Axe Bow

      The Shape at Front Decides How the Voyage Will Feel

       
      ∙
       
      Guest post
       
       
       
       
       

      READ IN APP

       
         
      The Ulstein X-Bow is one of the contenders, inspired by orcas.

      The man behind Ocean Explorer Yachts is Paul Madden, a specialist in expedition yacht conversions—transforming ice-class tugs, fisheries patrol vessels and offshore supply vessels into expedition yachts. He has channels on the subject on both Substack and YouTube. This Substack story first appeared on November 15 and is reprinted here with permission. The YouTube video is also posted below.


      Yacht builders are quite careful not to show you pictures of their vessels in heavy seas. But I can assure you: Any seasoned captain—yacht, military, or commercial—and any sailor who’s crossed an ocean has seen seas like that. Those pictures hit you right in the stomach, because you know what it feels like to hit a wave.

      You know the motion: How a ship rises off a wave and then dives off the far side just in time to catch the next one and start the roller coaster.

      So let’s talk about bows. There’s all kinds of chatter about the superiority of different designs—the aesthetics, the efficiencies, the economies, and just what looks cool and what doesn’t.

         
      She looks cool, but her affect on performance is more mythical than physical.

      First, a Step Into the Past

      Early ships kept it simple: The front of the vessel was the pointy end. Then they jazzed them up with elaborate figureheads, and I’ve been studying the messages built into them. “Don’t mess with me,” obviously some are quite aggressive.

      Predominantly they’re women. Some mysterious. Some like to show a little skin. I don’t know if that’s politically correct anymore. And one very angry woman who, if you look closely at her left hand, is holding somebody’s scalp. That could be a message for the crew. That could be an angry wife. The message might be: Don’t mess around in foreign ports.

      And lest anybody think today’s radical bow shapes are completely original and modern—pay homage to the French, British, and German dreadnoughts of a hundred-plus years ago. Warships carried some radical bows, shaped not just to cut through waves but to ram other vessels and sink them. I’ll leave it to others to comment on whether any yacht owners have used that criteria in designing theirs.

      Check the bow on the SS Delphine, the 257-foot American-built yacht from 1921, built for the Dodge family. There is nothing new under the sun.

         
      The 1921 motoryacht Delfine is shows the long heritage behind today’s fine-entry vessels.

      Why This Matters

      When you watch yacht videos, they’re always in flat seas. Perfect conditions. Sunny. No champagne glasses falling over, no water slopping out of the jacuzzi.

      But sooner or later, every vessel ends up in severe weather — intentionally or not. And that’s where the shape of the bow decides how the vessel rides, what her sea-keeping is, and how fast she can pass through a sea. A vessel getting knocked straight up in the air by every wave, digging tons of water across the foredeck, is not operating at her optimal capacity. That’s before you get to the safety considerations — green water smashing tenders and coming through windows — and the comfort of the people aboard. When a vessel is pitching like that, there’s going to be a lot of people puking. Let’s be honest about it.

      This is why naval architects and builders in the commercial and military sectors are innovating as fast as they can.

      Two Contenders

      The two biggest players in the bow wars are Ulstein in Norway—who developed and patented the X-Bow and have built more than 100 of them over fifteen years—and the Damen shipbuilding group in the Netherlands, who developed and patented the Sea Axe. Both companies make very convincing cases.

         
      Sea Axe design as compared to the X-Bow at the top of the story.

      The X-Bow’s argument: Sharper angles split the wave and the forces more evenly—and further back, toward the vessel’s center of gravity. I like that Ulstein points to the orca as part of the inspiration. An orca can weigh six tons, run 32 feet long, and hit 35 knots. That’s quite phenomenal.

      In the tank tests, you can see it plainly. The conventional flared bow throws a bigger bow wave—more smashing, more pitching and slower, because it takes energy to throw all that water out of the way. And Damen’s test—40 knots into two-meter waves—shows their hull slicing through beautifully.

      You’ll also notice it’s a narrow hull. That’s the defining feature of the Sea Axe boats: narrow beam, fast, less volume, though you can make up volume by going longer. And they are very cool looking. Much sexier than the X-Bows, I would say.

      Video With Tank Tests and More Figureheads

      Where I Land

      I grew up racing sailboats, sitting on the windward rail, getting hit by every wave you see coming. So I’m acutely aware of pitch and motion in heavy weather. Anything that makes that experience less jarring, I’m all for. On a big vessel, cutting through a wave rather than slamming into it, rising up, and crashing down the other side—that’s all got to be good.

      Between the X-Bow and the Sea Axe, the pluses mostly depend on the mission. For a big-volume vessel—probably anything over 70 meters—the X-Bow is the way to go. For a smaller vessel that wants to go fast, the Sea Axe. But understand the trade: Less volume, less form stability on a hull that narrow, which means stabilizers, and stabilizers cut into your efficiency.

      Anybody who’s going to build or convert a serious ocean-going yacht should be studying these alternatives seriously. The front of the ship decides how the whole voyage feels.

      LOOSE CANNON covers hard news, technical issues and nautical history. Every so often he tries to be funny. Subscribe for free to support the work. If you’ve been reading for a while—and you like it—consider upgrading to paid.

      Be the first to comment!


    Social Media Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com